“The Biggest Loser” – My Opinion
Monday, September 28th, 2009A client of mine just sent along a link to Tom Venuto’s blog site www.burnthefatblog.com. She thought I might find it interesting and she was right. In the blog this guy Tom writes his pros and cons of “The Biggest Loser”. I have to admit the guy is right on target with his points from a fitness guru and a fitness enthusiast point of view. However I have to question the last time he or any of his fellow followers have personally tried to drop 35 – 150 lbs in their past. And if per chance they have had the opportunity to be fat before and worked their way fit do they remember the obstacles on that journey back to fit? In fact when was the last time Tom personally trained someone off the street(not a top athlete who wants it) who had to lose a substantial amount of weight? I would love to know that answer. In fact most of the respondants on his blog who are fitness trainers, personal trainers and the like….who are you training that you can’t relate to “The Biggest Loser” or if you can’t relate then at least take the good parts and use it for your clients good? Or is it just too disgusting for you…that was a few comments. Yes Bob and Jillian have some issues but….it’s a show!
Well I have to tell you right now that I LIKE “The Biggest Loser” and I am a fitness professional for many years myself. There are many parts of the show that I feel are absolutely essential to someone overcoming their weight issues. First and of the most important factor is the HOPE ingredient. Tom touched very briefly on the hope and motivation aspect of the show which is quite an understatement. It is the primary reason the show is such a success. Yes it is a show and yes their is drama but so is life….whose life has no drama? And yes they do sell stuff…it is a reality show.
Next really, really important part of the show is when they review the contestants medicines and what they are for. Last season they had a guy on their that was 27 years old and he was taking something like 9 drugs just to live. THIS IS AN EYE OPENER. Yes that is what this show does for regular people. Makes them realize that what they are putting into their mouths everyday is affecting their health and wellbeing. You are not born fat, you work at it all day long and feed yourself all kinds of stuff and one day you wake up and you are taking 9 medications and are 200lbs overweight and how did this happen? This show makes regular people realize that there are many others like themselves and that they are pretty much responsible for their current physical situation…not genetics, not mom, not anyone or anything else…
At our studio we have worked with all kinds of people looking to drop 20lbs and upwards to 150lbs and I have to tell you that first they must BELIEVE they can lose the weight. Do they have the vision? Can they imagine it? Well after watching “The Biggest Loser” they will at least believe it can be done. Most of the time these overweight people of even as low as 20 lbs believe “I have been this weight since…..can I really lose it?” Of course you can. And with healthy eating and exercise you will achieve your goals of a healthy and fit body. No you won’t lose it in a week like “The Biggest Loser” but you can change your life. And most important is the FACT that with healthy eating and exercise YOU WILL LOSE WEIGHT. In my world many, many people just do not believe they can really lose weight.
Is it healthy what they do on TBL? Not so healthy I am sure to drop 25lbs in a week but I personally know many people who cut their calories to 500 a day for months, get shots to suppress their hunger of who really knows what, who pick up bad habits like smoking to curb appetite, who puke in the toilet, who just stop eating, who get lipo or gastric bypass, who exercise 4 hours a day….and they aren’t on “The Biggest Loser” so…..what’s the answer?
I absolutely agree that there is no reason for F bombs while training these people and I don’t like that they use scale weight to measure contestants progress. But in my world….just about every client that walks in the door is ONLY concerned about what the scale says. And yes it is up to us to teach them what it’s really all about like health and fitness….but I still love the show… and will watch it…
Would love to hear your feedback…
God Bless You,
Evey
